Section

Official Delhi air quality figures may mask the severity of Diwali pollution by excluding extreme PM2.5 spikes, raising trust concerns.
BBC Verify has identified significant discrepancies in official Indian government datasets regarding Delhi's air pollution levels during Diwali, suggesting that widely cited figures may not reflect the true severity of the crisis. As fireworks illuminated Delhi’s skies on November 8, marking one of India’s most significant festivals, monitoring stations recorded alarming spikes in PM2.5, a fine particulate matter capable of causing severe lung damage and other serious health issues.
However, every hourly PM2.5 reading exceeding 1,000 micrograms per cubic metre was systematically excluded from the Air Quality Index (AQI) published by the Central Pollution Control Board (CPCB). This exclusion occurred even though the higher readings were clearly present in the data collected by the Delhi Pollution Control Commission (DPCC). Delhi is already recognized as one of the most polluted cities globally, facing dangerously poor air quality due to vehicle emissions, construction dust, farm fires, and atmospheric factors, with firecrackers significantly worsening conditions during winter.
The CPCB, whose figures are predominantly cited by Indian media, stated in a statement that it is "committed to transparent, scientific and reliable reporting." The board explained that readings above 1,000 micrograms are treated as "outside" the range for which its equipment has been calibrated and are therefore excluded from calculations. "During extreme episodes which are occasional like Diwali firecracker bursting, this may appear as a data gap at the particular station concerned, and those hours do not contribute to the 24-hour average of relevant pollutant for concerned station," the statement added.
Despite these justifications, an analysis by BBC Verify revealed a stark contrast in reported numbers. Across the same 30 stations over a 24-hour period covering Diwali night, the available CPCB readings averaged 240 micrograms per cubic metre. This figure is less than half the average of 551 micrograms found in the DPCC’s corresponding data.
The data gaps were particularly pronounced during the peak of celebrations. Between 21:00 local time on November 8 and 07:00 on November 9, 217 hourly PM2.5 observations were missing across 59 CPCB monitoring stations in Delhi. Only 16 stations reported complete data during this critical window, while 43 stations had at least one missing observation. Consequently, none of the 116 readings above 1,000 micrograms from the 116 DPCC-managed stations appeared in the CPCB's published records, despite the latter feeding into the same data infrastructure.
The methodological implications are substantial. According to CPCB methodology, stations require at least 16 hours of valid PM2.5 measurements to calculate a daily average. Stations with too many missing or invalid readings do not contribute to official pollution calculations, effectively removing the most polluted hours from public view.
For instance, a monitoring station at RK Puram in south Delhi recorded pollution peaking at nearly 2,500 micrograms. Using hourly PM2.5 readings from this location, BBC Verify calculated an average concentration of approximately 945 micrograms over the 24-hour period after 17:00 on November 8. In contrast, similar averages from CPCB’s published data for 14 of those 24 hours produced a significantly lower figure of 299 micrograms. The missing 10 hours from this station meant its data was entirely excluded from daily averages.
This systemic omission influenced the reported city-wide status. Despite a sharp overnight rise in pollution at several monitoring stations, the CPCB reported Delhi's AQI at 344 at 16:00 on November 9, down from 376 at the same time the previous day.
Dr. Manoj Kumar, a researcher at the Centre for Research on Energy and Clean Air (CREA), told BBC Verify that excluding high readings risks misrepresenting actual pollution levels and could cause people to lose trust in official figures. He noted that while firecrackers are not the sole cause of pollution, they exacerbate the problem during winter months.
The exclusion of extreme values has direct public health implications. Dr. Sierra Clark, an environmental epidemiologist from City St George's, University in London, warned that classifying high pollution readings as missing could leave out days which "contribute the most to short-term health events, such as asthma attacks and heart attacks."
"The latter would give a sense of typical pollution levels that are more representative of people's day-to-day experience. But it is also important to show the impact of those few days and what they contribute," Dr. Clark added. Government critics and opposition parties have accused the government of deliberately under-reporting pollution data, a claim the CPCB rejected by citing scientific calibration standards.
The revelation that extreme PM2.5 spikes were systematically filtered out during a major pollution event highlights a critical vulnerability in how air quality is reported in India. If the CPCB continues to rely on equipment calibration limits that ignore real-world extremes, the resulting AQI data will fail to capture the true health burden borne by residents. This discrepancy between DPCC and CPCB data suggests that without recalibrating monitoring protocols to include peak pollution hours, official metrics will consistently understate the immediate dangers of air pollution during festivals. Future policy decisions and public health advisories based on this incomplete data may prove insufficient, leaving vulnerable populations exposed to unreported risks. As Delhi remains one of the world’s most polluted cities, ensuring that monitoring equipment captures the full spectrum of pollution, including dangerous peaks, is essential for maintaining public trust and safeguarding community health.
Nov 17, 2026 16:45 UTC
US Intel Warns of Iran Dirty Bomb Plot in DC
Nov 17, 2026 12:48 UTC
Quad Summit Manila: Modi, Trump Focus on Indo-Pacific Security
Nov 17, 2026 10:43 UTC
Ukraine Strike Collapses Crimean Bridge Ahead of Diplomatic Talks
Nov 16, 2026 16:25 UTC
Beijing Claims Historic Significance for Trilateral Talks in Shenzhen
Nov 16, 2026 18:23 UTC
Cyclone Akvan: Storm System Intensifies Toward Andhra Pradesh